6/20/2012 9:41:11 AM
As it turned out, the Kum Ba Yah period didn't even last 10 months.
The ever-present disharmony between the league and the Players Association was
back to lockout-like levels following Monday's abbreviated hearing for the
four current or former New Orleans Saints players suspended by Roger Goodell
for their participation in the team's alleged bounty program, further
heightening the tension that had already been raised by the commissioner's
controversial ruling on that issue and two other subjects that also drew the
ire of the union: the reduction of salary cap space for two teams found to be
front-loading player contracts during the uncapped 2010 season and a recent
mandate on knee and thigh pads for 2013.
Monday's developments included cries of outrage and injustice from the accused
over the appeals process, the persistent presence of high-profile attorneys,
subtle signs of simmering frustration within the union ranks -- and to no
surprise, no immiment resolution in sight.
And perhaps most notably, the introduction of evidence that appears to damage
the increasingly fragile claims that Jonathan Vilma, Anthony Hargrove, Will
Smith and Scott Fujita have made regarding their innocence.
The four defendants looked to have a much stronger case earlier in the day due
to the NFL's reluctance to disclose much of the information it had uncovered
during its thorough investigation of the pay-for-performance scheme run by
exiled ex-Saints defensive coordinator Gregg Williams. But when backed into a
corner by the union and the players' counsel, the league unleashed a mountain
of testimony and documents that has lended much more credence to the notion
that a bounty program did indeed exist.
That the Saints had a system where defensive players received monetary bonuses
for such accomplishments as turnovers, sacks and impact hits wasn't in
dispute. Williams, who's ironically become the league's star witness in its
quest to punish the suspended players, had already admitted as much when
probed by NFL security officials. Slides taken from team computers, including
one that featured famed bounty hunter and reality television star Duane "Dog"
Chapman among pictures of several key Seattle Seahawks that was presumably
used as a motivational piece prior to a 2010 playoff game, that were made
public on Monday offered further proof.
The NFL still hasn't demonstrated beyond a reasonable doubt that Williams'
players were instructed -- and compensated -- for deliberately injuring
opponents, or provided the hard facts to back up its claims that Vilma offered
$10,000 to any teammate who could knock out Brett Favre and Kurt Warner during
the Saints' 2009 playoff run. And as the trials of O.J. Simpson, Barry Bonds
and Roger Clemens have shown, it can be awfully challenging to pin something
on a famous athlete with the resources to hire an all-star defense team and
make it stick.
But because of these latest findings, it's now infinitely easier to draw the
conclusion that the evidence against the players is likely there, and the
league's only withholding all of its smoking guns to conceal the identities of
It may not be an open-and-shut case, but the new revelations do make it much
harder to attach any credibility to Vilma, the quarterback of the New Orleans
defense and one of Williams' most trusted charges who's repeatedly denied any
knowledge of a bounty program. And truth be told, why should he be fully taken
at his word? This isn't the first time he's been linked to an underground
money-for-punishment operation, as the ex-University of Miami star was a known
associate of convicted felon Nevin Shapiro, the infamous onetime Hurricanes'
booster who told Yahoo! Sports last summer he paid Vilma to injure opposing
players on multiple occasions. And there's a paper trail long enough to extend
from Coral Gables to South Beach on that charge.
Of course, that doesn't make Vilma guilty of anything more than using very
poor judgement in the past company he's kept as it pertains to this situation.
Still, his rant about having his good name destroyed by an wrongful witch hunt
by Goodell is becoming about as believable as the NFLPA's weak defense that
Williams' use of incriminating words such as "kill the head" and "cart-off"
and the likeliness of Dog the Bounty Hunter in his game plans were merely
poorly chosen metaphors that shouldn't be taken literally.
Vilma's complaints about not getting a fair shake in an appeals system where
Goodell ranks as "judge, jury and executioner" carry more validity, though
blaming the wrong people for his plight. The union acquiesced to having the
commissioner maintain absolute authority on all player discipline matters in
the new CBA agreement, thereby tying the hands of those it's supposed to
represent in scenarios such as this one. Fujita's public criticism of the
process holds even less weight than his fellow suspended mates, as he was one
of the 32 player representatives who consented to the deal.
Whether Goodell is abusing the enormous power he wields can be called into
question, but the fact of the matter is he's well within his right to do so as
long as the league's story checks out.
A TAKE ON TOMLINSON
An unfortunate consequence from Monday's events was how they overshadowed what
should have been a day dedicated to LaDainian Tomlinson, who signed a
ceremonial one-day contract with the San Diego Chargers to retire with the
team in which the legendary running back spent the majority of his brilliant
Then again, it's probably fitting that Tomlinson, who turns 33 on Saturday,
was forced to cede the spotlight. The two-time rushing champion and six-time
All-Pro wasn't just one of the greatest players of his era, but one of the
most unassuming ones as well. His prolific on-field accomplishments were
matched by his refreshing humility and charitable contributions away from it,
with the native Texan earning the NFL's Walter Payton Man of the Year Award in
2006 and the Athletes in Action/Bart Starr Award the following year for his
And those in-game achievements were indeed hard to top. Tomlinson averaged
over 1,500 rushing yards and 2,000 yards from scrimmage with the Chargers over
his first seven seasons, while scoring an incredible 129 touchdowns during
that superb stretch. His 162 total touchdowns are eclipsed only by Jerry Rice
and Emmitt Smith on the NFL's career list, and his 13,684 rushing yards rank
As is customarily the case whenever a transcendent player decides to hang up
his cleats, Tomlinson's retirement has sparked plenty of discussion over where
he stands in the overall hierarchy among running backs. Whether Tomlinson was
superior or not to Marshall Faulk, Thurman Thomas, Marcus Allen and Payton --
the greats he's most often compared to -- is really a matter of semantics,
Let's just leave it at this: All four of those mentioned above are in the Pro
Football Hall of Fame, and Tomlinson is certain to be joining them in Canton
as soon as he's eligible for induction in 2018.
And that's a subject that isn't up for debate.